Mr. Monk and the Two Assistants by Goldberg, Lee (books for students to read .TXT) 📕

“Just his priest,” Maurice said.

CHAPTER EIGHTEEN

Mr. Monk Goes to Church

Monk decided he wanted to try talking to Father Bowen at morning mass, so we called it a day. I thought that would be a good idea. It would also give Stottlemeyer a chance to call Father Bowen and warn him that we were coming. I didn’t want to try finesse on a priest. I was in enough trouble with God as it was.

But I wasn’t ready to let Monk off without knowing what he was thinking, not only about the Webster case but about Trevor as well. And when he was in my car, he was a captive audience. So I took the long way back to his place, which practically meant giving him a tour of downtown San Francisco.

“What makes you so sure that Ronald Webster’s death was murder?” I asked.

“He was attacked by an alligator,” Monk said.

“It could happen,” I said.

“If he was in a bayou,” he said, “not on a beach in San Francisco.”

“What about the possibility that someone’s pet alligator escaped and attacked him?”

“That means the alligator either had to scurry across the open sand to get him,” Monk said. “Or it was waiting for prey near the tide pools and struck when he sat down on the rocks to undress. I have a hard time believing either scenario.”

“Maybe Ronald took a swim, drowned and, when his body washed up on the beach, the alligator attacked it.”

“I suppose that could have happened,” Monk said. “But I don’t believe it, either.”

“Why not?”

“Because it doesn’t seem to fit with his personality as the other shoe salesman described it,” Monk said, “and because it’s ridiculous.”

“Ridiculous things happen,” I said. “Imagine what people thought when they saw you walking around Los Angeles wearing a gas mask.”

“What was ridiculous about that?”

There was no point trying to explain that to him, so I let it drop. “What else makes you think this was murder and not a freak accident?”

“His car wasn’t there,” Monk said. “My guess is that we’re going to find it parked near his home or the shoe store. That whole situation at the beach was staged by whoever took him to the beach to make it look like he was skinny-dipping or nude sunbathing when he was killed.”

“So you think the alligator attack was faked?”

“That’s the simple explanation and the one that makes the most sense. The medical examiner should be able to determine if it’s fakery or not easily enough.”

“Why would someone want to make it look like Ronald Webster was killed by an alligator on a nude beach?”

“That’s the mystery,” Monk said.

It was certainly a far more intriguing and Monk-like puzzlethan Ellen Cole’s murder, which I’m sure made it a lot more compelling for Monk. That, and it was happening in San Francisco and not in the toxic environs of Los Angeles.

“It’s one mystery,” I said. “You still have another one to solve. Who really killed Ellen Cole? Sharona is counting on you to find out. So is Benji. And so am I.”

Monk squirmed in his seat. “It’s not so easy.”

I gave him a look. “Someone hit Ellen Cole on the head with a lamp. It’s not nearly as complicated and bizarre as most of the cases you solve.”

“In a way, it’s too simple,” Monk said, “which makes it complex.”

“I don’t understand.”

“The more things that don’t fit, that don’t make sense, the more I have to go on in my investigation,” Monk said. “Someone killed by an alligator on a nude beach is so inherently wrong that there are all kinds of questions to ask and inconsistencies I can ponder. All I know about Ellen Cole is that someone besides Trevor hit her with a lamp.”

“And framed Trevor for it,” I said.

“Or not,” Monk said. “Trevor could be innocent of murder and still guilty of everything else he’s accused of. He just made a handy fall guy. There isn’t anything else out of place for me to explore.”

“It’s not like there’s a shortage of suspects,” I said.

“All of whom have solid alibis and good explanations for why they wouldn’t have benefited from her death.”

“That’s never been an obstacle for you,” I said.

“I believe them,” Monk said. “I don’t think either Ellen’s lover or her lover’s lover or her lover’s lover’s wife killed her.”

I was getting lost following who was who, but I got his point, even if it wasn’t the one he necessarily intended to make.

“So you ran away,” I said.

“Of course I did,” Monk said. “You saw the people down there. You saw the air. You are not supposed to be able to see air. Or chew it.”

“That’s not why you ran,” I said.

“It’s why I ran screaming,” he said.

“You fled Los Angeles because you are afraid of failing,” I said. “You have no idea who killed Ellen Cole and don’t know where to start looking.”

“I know I’m not going to find the answer by staying in Los Angeles and questioning everyone who was remotely involved with either Ellen Cole or Trevor Fleming.”

“Isn’t that how you usually investigate a crime, by asking questions, learning new information and spotting contradictions?”

Monk shook his head. “I solve it the first time I visit the crime scene. I see something that isn’t right, and by trying to make things fit, I figure out how the murder was really committed.”

“You saw lots of things that weren’t right at Ellen Cole’s house.”

“But not the thing,” he said.

“And you think you will see it here?” I said. “We’re hundreds of miles away.”

“I’ve already seen it,” Monk said. “I just haven’t realized it yet.”

It all made sense to me now. “You’re worried that you never will,” I said.

“It’s